Only 1 left Ready now
6" Minecraft Cake
$50 pick up today
Add to bag Order sweets today
In the case right now
No forms. No waiting on a quote. 41 things are boxed and ready this minute. Add what you want to your bag, check out once, and it is ready about 20 minutes later.
Indianapolis's most-awarded cake bakery
1,500+ five-star reviews on 
All sales final · No refunds · No exchanges
Tick the box to turn on checkout. You can fill your bag either way. Checkout is on. Add what you want below. Read our order policies.
Finished, boxed, in the case
Today's cakes
6 cakes are already decorated and waiting. 6 of them are the only one of their kind, so the one you are looking at is the one you get.
Only 1 left 
Only 1 left Ready now
6" Black Cat Cake
$48 pick up today
Add to bag 
Only 1 left Ready now
6" Orange Cat Cake
$48 pick up today
Add to bag 
Only 1 left Ready now
6” Furry Monster Cake
$48 pick up today
Add to bag 
Only 1 left Ready now
6” Candy Corn Cake
$45 pick up today
Add to bag 
Only 1 left Ready now
6" Celebration Sprinkle Cake
$40 pick up today
Add to bag One bite, no fork
Cake pops
Iced, XL and gourmet
Cookies
Cookies
Halloween
$5 Choose color
Only 3 left Cookie Cake
Personalized (Add a message!)
$30 Choose color
Gourmet Cookies
Chocolate Chip
$2 Add to bag
Only 1 left Gourmet Brownies
Spider Web Cookies and Scream Brownies
$3.75 Add to bag
Lemon Blueberry Cookies
$3 Add to bag
Gourmet Cookies
M&M Cookie
$2 Add to bag
By the dozen or the pair
Cupcakes
Under five dollars
Macarons & treats
Do not forget
Add to your order
Nobody drives across town for a number candle. But you are already checking out.
Big Gold Numbers
$5
Small Glitter Numbers
$2.50
Big Glitter Numbers
$3.50
Birthday, Graduation, Baby Shower
$5
Kids Themed
from $1
24 Pack
$3
Gold Number Toppers
$3
Small Gold Numbers
$2.50
Silver Number Toppers
$3
Trick Candle
$4
Only 1 Medium Gold Number
$3
Only 1 6” Candle Cake
$45
Only 2 Medium Rose Gold Number
$3
Only 3 Medium Silver Number
$3
Only 2 Medium Black Number
$3
Letter Packs
$5
Big Rainbow Numbers
$4
Custom cakes
Want it built your way?
The case is one thing. A cake made for your date, your colors and your very specific opinions about buttercream is another. Tell us what you are picturing and we will price it out.
Get a custom quoteWeddings
Book a cake tasting
Sit down with us, eat cake for an hour, and leave with a plan. It is the best hour of wedding planning you will have, and it is where every wedding cake we make starts.